I'm tired of the FUD about ASDI-down and boxx. As a decade-long GCC claw player before switching to boxx for accessibility (CMC arthritis in the left thumb), I don't feel like there is an appreciable difference between the two for this tech.
I'll use ASDI-down Peach subfloat since that seems to be the current FUD example people throw around:
- Cstick ASDI down with claw vs boxx both use two fingers. Index+thumb on claw and middle+thumb on boxx.
- Cstick ASDI down is not an especially analog input, so the analog-ness of the Cstick doesn't really matter.
- Cstick ASDI down with claw and an analog Cstick puts less strain on my right hand than on boxx.
- Because 1) it's less of a reach (my gram slim is like 2x the distance between Cdown and jump than a gcc) and 2) you don't have to "press" with the thumb perpendicular to your grip but can instead use a more natural thumb motion parallel to your grip.
- I actually